June 9, 2006
Rober Browning in his famed poem titled - The Pied Piper of Hamelin
Into the street the Piper stept,
Smiling first a little smile,
As if he knew what magic slept
In his quiet pipe the while;
Then, like a musical adept,
To blow the pipe his lips he wrinkled,
And green and blue his sharp eyes twinkled,
Like a candle-flame where salt is sprinkled;
And ere three shrill notes the pipe uttered,
You heard as if an army muttered;
And the muttering grew to a grumbling;
And the grumbling grew to a mighty rumbling;
And out of the houses the rats came tumbling.
Great rats, small rats, lean rats, brawny rats,
Brown rats, black rats, gray rats, tawny rats,
Grave old plodders, gay young friskers,
Fathers, mothers, uncles, cousins,
Cocking tails and pricking whiskers,
Families by tens and dozens,
Brothers, sisters, husbands, wives–
Followed the Piper for their lives.
From street to street he piped advancing,
And step for step they followed dancing,
Until they came to the river Weser
Wherein all plunged and perished!
The poem could well have been titled -the Pied Piper of Inida!
Why, you may ask, do I say this?
Before answering your question, let me explain my view of the story.
It was said that Pied Piper possessed some magical powers that enabled him to attract the rats of Hamelin, and lead them to their death. In fact, the truth is this - a few of the rats liked the music he played, and so they followed him. The rest of the rats simply followed these other rats!
That is what is happening in our great country, India!
It has been always said unity makes one stronger. But unity at the cosy of individuality will make you weeker! India is driven by the crowd mentality or what I now name the Pied Piper mentality! 90% of Indians are busy doing things because that is what every one else is doing.
Let us take a few examples -
First, let us evaluate the education system in India.
What does education mean to a middle class family? If the kid is extremely good academically, he or she studies medicine, the next level of people rush into engineering. The rest filter into Commerce and arts! Why? Not always because the field they choose interests them, but because they just follow the rat in front! In this mad rush, the only looser is individuality! Just because an individual is brilliant academically, does not mean that he or she is best suited to be a doctor! Mind you, when I say Doctor, I mean the guy that saves lives, not that mean money making machine! On the same token, not every student that fails miserably academically, deserves to be relegated to the, so-called ‘non professional’ colleges!
The latest buzz word in the world of education is ‘MBA’. Every one wants to do it. Why? It helps me further my career! How, may I ask? Yes there are a few career paths that move faster if armed with an MBA, but most only find this extra degree a burden! Armed with an MBA, the Doctor wants to sit in a large office, managing people, rather than saving lives. Armed with an MBA , an Engineer, wants to keep his hands clean! If all you wanted to do was ‘manage’ then why did you waste expensive resources that were employed to make you an Engineer or a Doctor? Hey, because I could! BS
The Pied Piper mentality can be seen in other facets of life. Lets take cricket! Do not get me wrong, I love the game. I follow every cricket match that features India (and some that do not.) I, like most Indians, am the happiest when India wins and the saddest when India looses! Maybe its the fact that I am away from my country, or maybe that I have become wiser, but now I feel that cricket is highly detrimental to the Indian society! This one game has been responsible for a drainage of a lot of resources. If a nation can have 23 world class cricket grounds all over the nation, I am sure it can afford a few astroturf hockey grounds, so that India can regain some lost glory. Most younsters may not even know that Hockey is our national game. We invented it for crying out loud! If a nation can have cricket coaching camps in every third corner of every city, it can surely have a few football coaching facilities! The MRF pace foundation churns out great fast bowlers! Why can’t a company sponsor a football academy. An academy that takes in youngsters and moulds them into great football players? Why? Cause we are rats, and we follow the rats in front!
Followed the Piper for their lives.
From street to street he piped advancing,
And step for step they followed dancing,
Until they came to the river Weser
Wherein all plunged and perished!
Wake up Indians before we follow the Pied Piper to the river, and perish!
Let us unite without loosing our individuality! Let us form a team of individuals that do follow a common goal, but a goal that is forumated from a set of indivdual goals!
Let us put the Pied Piper to rest once and for all!
June 13, 2006 at 12:20 am
Quite an interesting post! Yes alot of us are just ‘following’ somebody else like those rats followed to the tune of the Pied Piper…we r not being unique and we r afraid to tread the untrodden territories..cos we r so used to copying! Just look at Bollywood movies..so much copying of the West!
Keshi.
June 13, 2006 at 12:32 am
yes, exactly. If we go down history lane, and pick up the best Bollywood movies, we will very easily realize that most are based on a western (or a south Indian) movie. Take the Sholays, the jewel thiefs, satte pe satta - great movies all, but unfortunately not original. Even last year’s famed Black was based on The Miracle Worker
June 13, 2006 at 10:32 pm
aha…we r so hooked up with the Western world. Sad!
Keshi.
July 3, 2006 at 10:48 am
Excellent post. I loved the poem!
Now, I have an argument to make.
“If the kid is extremely good academically, he or she studies medicine, the next level of people rush into engineering. ”
If a kid isnt interested, he himself need not choose engineering but maybe forced to do so. Basically, he’s not making the decisions but his parents. His parents present a narrow band of choices: “Engineering or medicine?” The kid’s got to choose one of these. If he says “I want to study History”, then a exasperated reply comes, “Will you roam on the roads after studying History?!” In fact, the parents may not be entirely false because they know that something like history might not be as “rewarding” (in getting a lucrative job that is) as engineering or medicine for their kid. The problem is that today, the concern of every individual is to make money as much money as possible first and the rest later. So, I guess it is not totally due to crowd behaviour or herd behaviour
July 3, 2006 at 12:03 pm
Well ‘making money’ being termed as the only path forward is a herd behaviour is it not?
Anyway, my beef is not only with students following the herd, but also with there not being opportinities in other fields of study! My beef is that today’s young Indian does not have it in him to create opportunities. yes there are more jobs available for engineers and doctors. But, not every one can be one! So , instead of following the herd, we need a few that say ‘ What the hell, I will find my own unique path and survive’ !
July 5, 2006 at 4:36 pm
I recognise herd behaviour. After all, it happens in all animals and we are no exception. But I’m saying that herd behaviour apart, in humans, there are a lot of cultural factors influencing behaviour.
Making money is not the only path forward. I agree but money is indispensable. Even the best professor in the world wont teach if he isnt paid anything. This is not to say that the professor has only money on his mind but still…
Anyway, lack of opportunities may also be forcing students to study in engg and medicine, to study which, there are many opportunities. The money that circulates in these fields also acts like a significant added attraction, like a vital catalyst. Monetary prospects might make the difference in a person choosing between history and engineering. I think it also depends on the financial background of the person. If he’s already rich, he might not care much about money and might choose history acc. to his interests while a person who is poor and wants to advance himself financially, chooses engg. even going against his interests.
Anyway, I’m turning this into a psychology debate :p Atleast I agree that people should stop allowing other people influence them and recognise that all fields are equally important and rewarding.
Btw, I’ve filed the reply to your comment on my blog.
Regards
July 6, 2006 at 3:40 am
I take what victories I get
Atleast you agree with me conceptually!
I agree that financial constraints drive ppl to Engineering vs history. And it will take generations before ppl realize the value of diversity. Here’s hoping that the day comes sooner than later!